Apple Cider Sangria (Caramel Vodka Fall Sangria)

An easy apple cider sangria recipe with caramel vodka, crisp Pinot Grigio, and real apple cider. It can be made ahead of time and double or tripled for parties!

overhead view of a glass of Apple Cider Sangria

Why this recipe works

I’ll be honest with you. I prefer this apple cider sangria over other recipes out there for two reasons. One is that I am using fresh, unfiltered apple cider, which has so much more flavor! Another reason is that I prefer this to actually taste like a sangria, not just a spiked juice. A lot of recipes tend to go heavy on the cider, which muddles down the other ingredients. I feel like I’ve balanced the flavors enough so that you can still taste the wine and the caramel vodka against the cider. You can most definitely adjust the alcohol ratios to fit your tastes!

Caramel apple cider sangria is great for Thanksgiving, Friendsgiving, and even Halloween parties since it makes an entire pitcher’s worth of drinks. You can easily double or triple it for larger batches. I personally think it’s even better made in advance, which makes it a lot easier than preparing individual cocktails for each guest. I make a batch (sometimes two) of it every year along with cranberry sangria for the Thanksgiving spread!

overhead view of two glasses of Apple Cider Sangria

Ingredients you will need

Get all measurements, ingredients, and instructions in the printable version at the end of this post.

Ingredient Info and Substitution Suggestions

APPLE CIDER – Look for fresh, unfiltered, unsweetened cider in the refrigerated section of the produce department, or pick some up at an orchard if you have one nearby. Apple juice will work in a pinch, but it is filtered and sweeter, and the sangria will taste noticeably flatter. If juice is all you can find, you can try adding a tablespoon of fresh lemon juice to bring back some brightness.

CARAMEL VODKA – Smirnoff Kissed Caramel and Pinnacle salted caramel are both easy to find and both work well here. If your store does not carry a caramel version, use plain vodka and add an extra tablespoon or two of caramel sauce to the pitcher. Whipped cream vodka is a good substitute if you want something a little softer and creamier. I’ve also used Smirnoff Green Apple Vodka in the past when the stores were completely sold out of caramel vodka.

PINOT GRIGIO – Use a full 750 ml bottle. You want a dry, crisp white with some acid to it. Sauvignon Blanc is also a good choice. I wouldn’t personally recommend Chardonnay because it’s a little too buttery and oaky. Moscato is too sweet against an already sweet cider and caramel vodka base, so I also wouldn’t recommend using it.

APPLES – Use one red and one Granny Smith so you get both colors floating in the pitcher and a little tartness against all that caramel. I use Honeycrisp for the red apple, but Gala and Fuji are also great. Whatever you pick, stay away from softer, low-acid varieties, because they break down quicker.

CARAMEL SAUCE – Any thick jarred caramel or ice cream topping works. Most of it gets drizzled over the apples in the bottom of the pitcher before anything else goes in. Save a little on a small plate for rimming the glasses! Warm the caramel for a few seconds if it’s stiff from the refrigerator, or it clumps instead of spreading.

How to Make Apple Cider Sangria

These step by step photos and instructions are here to help you visualize how to make this recipe. You can Jump to Recipe to get the printable version of this recipe, complete with measurements and instructions at the bottom.

Cut apples into bite sized chunks and place into the pitcher. Drizzle caramel over the apples.
Pour in the entire bottle of Pinot Grigio then add the caramel vodka.
Top with the apple cider and stir a few times. Add pomegranate arils. Chill in the refrigerator for 3-4 hours.
To serve, add caramel sauce to one small plate and turbinado sugar to another small plate. Dip the rim of your glass into the caramel and lift straight up. If caramel is thin, allow excess to drip off.
Dip rim straight down into the turbinado sugar then lift straight up.
Carefully pour sangria into the glass, filling about halfway. You can scoop out additional apples with a spoon to add to the glass if needed.
Top with a few fresh pomegranate arils and a star anise.

Frequently Asked Questions & Expert Tips

How do I keep the apples from turning brown?

Chop your apples and drop them into a bowl of cold water with a squeeze of lemon juice while you gather everything else. Drain them right before they go into the pitcher. Once the pieces are submerged in the sangria they are fine, since the liquid keeps air off them. It is the sitting around on the cutting board that tends to brown them.

How long should it chill?

At least two hours, though overnight is even better! Thirty minutes will get you a cold drink, but it tastes more blended after chilling for longer. Around the two hour mark the caramel has fully dissolved and the apples have started releasing flavor into the mixture. Overnight is really best! Do not go past about three days, though, or the cider starts to turn and tastes a bit vinegary.

Can I make it without alcohol?

Yes. Replace the wine and vodka with two cups of white grape juice and one and a half cups of chilled club soda, added just before serving so it keeps its fizz. This version is great for kids or those who do not drink!

What size pitcher do I need?

A 3-quart pitcher, meaning one that holds around 12 cups filled to the top. The liquid comes to about 8 cups on its own, and the chopped apples make the total volume roughly 10 cups. A standard 2-quart pitcher holds 8 cups and will not fit this batch.
If you’re not sure what your pitcher holds, find out before you start by measuring water with a measuring cup. Don’t forget to account for some space at the top for adding the apples. Mine holds 12 cups filled right to the top, which leaves comfortable headroom for a 10-cup batch.
If yours turns out to be too small, either halve the recipe or build it in a punch bowl.

How do I make this ahead for Thanksgiving?

Mix the wine, cider, vodka, caramel, and chopped apples the night before then cover and refrigerate the pitcher. Add the pomegranate arils in the morning so they still look fresh. Keep the star anise pods on the side and drop one into each glass after you pour. The star anise will be way too strong if you add it into the pitcher itself. If you are doubling it for a crowd, use a punch bowl and hold back on the ice until people start pouring so the sangria doesn’t get watered down while it sits.

Can I swap the wine or the liquor?

Use white wine, and specifically a dry one. I tested this both ways and red is the weaker drink. The tannins fight the caramel so the flavor comes out muddled, and the color turns an unappealing brown instead of the amber you want.
The liquor can easily be swapped. Plain vodka plus an extra drizzle of caramel sauce can make it taste very similar. Spiced rum is good if you want something warmer, and bourbon works if you want the drink to be less sweet.

Apple Cider Sangria in a stemless wine glass

Storage and Freezing Information

Cover the pitcher tightly and refrigerate leftover sangria for up to three days. After that, the cider begins to ferment slightly and takes on a sour, vinegary taste. Strain out the apples after the first day. They go soft and mealy well before the sangria itself turns, and they will cloud the pitcher.

I do not recommend freezing this sangria as-is, since the alcohol keeps it from setting properly and the texture is grainy when it thaws. If you want a frozen version, pour the finished sangria into ice cube trays, freeze the cubes, and blend them into a slush right before serving.

Serving Suggestions

Pour your apple cider sangria over ice into stemless wine glasses rimmed with caramel and turbinado sugar. Optionally top with a star anise pod in each cocktail. If you want it sparkling, add a splash of prosecco, ginger ale, or club soda to each glass as you pour. Never put anything carbonated into the pitcher ahead of time, because it will be flat by the time you serve.

This sangria is great for Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving, Halloween parties, or served at a fall bonfire. A cheese board with sharp cheddar and candied nuts would pair really well, and so does a tray of bacon wrapped little smokies or a warm dip.

If you want more fall drinks for the same party, our spiked caramel apple cider is the warm counterpart to this one, made with the same caramel vodka but served in a mug. Caramel apple mimosas cover brunch the next morning, and for something non-alcoholic to set beside the pitcher, our hot apple cider is always the first thing to disappear. Enjoy!

More Party Drink Recipes

I love to bake and cook and share my kitchen experience with all of you! Remembering to come back each day can be tough, that’s why I offer a convenient newsletter every time a new recipe posts. Simply subscribe and start receiving your free daily recipes!

Author
Recent Posts

Amanda Davis

President at Amanda's Creative Studio, Inc.

I’m Amanda Davis, recipe developer, baking enthusiast, and founder of Amanda’s Cookin’. I’ve been cooking, baking, and creating trusted recipes for over 30 years. We create recipes for every cooking and baking level, because great food should be approachable and delicious. We hope you love our recipes as much as we do!

Apple Cider Sangria