Almost two weeks ago I posted my favorite brisket recipe. In that post I stated my fear of trying new brisket recipes. I mean really, if ain’t broke, why fix it, right? That day, my food blogging friend and TWD baking bud, Megan of My Baking Adventures, posted a comment that struck my interest. She said “I have a go-to brisket recipe that I’ve made so many times I have it memorized. I know I should branch out and try something new…. but…. I can’t! I stick with the same one because it always works and everyone loves it.”
Me too! So it seemed that Megan and I had the same problem. We were chicken. So I wrote to her and asked if she’d be up for a challenge that would take both her and I out of our comfort zone. We decided to each try a different recipe for brisket and report our results on our blogs. So when you’re done here, be sure to hop over to Megan’s and see what she cooked up and how it worked for her!
I chose one of the recipes I’ve had in my binder for a long time. I had pulled the page out of a Better Homes & Garden magazine and stored it away for future use. I did alter a couple of minor things, but nothing that would affect the flavor really. I’m giving you my adaption of the recipe below, the original one can be found here. I also had to chop everything in half as I used a 3 pound piece of meat, that’s plenty for us.
THE VERDICT: It was pretty good. Here’s my thoughts. If I’m going to cook something all day, it needs to knock my socks off. Don’t get me wrong, it was good, but it wasn’t great. The meat was nice and tender, the vegetables were perfect, but the flavor was kind of bland. Maybe I just had my expectations set too high, who knows. Everyone ate, everyone enjoyed it, including me, but it needed something. I’m glad I took this challenge with Megan, it’s made me a bit braver to try something different. I do plan on trying the recipe Megan did, it sounds delicious!
I will probably take this particular recipe and make it my own, but I will have to try some other recipes first. ;) This makes a nice starter recipe that you can make your own with herbs and other flavors you enjoy. Perhaps not refrigerating this overnight had something to do with the bland taste, but I’m not into 2 day recipes.
The first step is to brown some onion and garlic in oil in your baking pan.
Do this, stirring occasionally for ten minutes. Mine got nice and brown.
Put the brisket in the pan, over the onion mixture, and poor the broth mixture over the top. Now it bakes for 2 hours, covered.
Remove it from the oven and add the potatoes and carrots, then bake uncovered for another hour.
Remove it from the oven and cover it with foil, let it rest for 30 minutes. Then you separate the meat and vegies from the juices and refrigerate for a bit. After that, reduce the pan juices by boiling gently on the stove top, return everything to the pan, add thyme sprigs and cover with reduced juices. Bake again. Then make a roux and a gravy from the juices.
Savory Beef Brisket
adapted from Better Homes & Gardens
NEW! Be sure to subscribe to my newsletter, Foodie in the Craftroom, to receive updates and tips from both Amanda’s Cookin’ and Crafts by Amanda! Visit http://www.amandascookin.com/p/subscribe-to-newsletter.html