Portobello Salisbury Steaks

Portobello Salisbury Steaks

Comfort food. It’s defined as food that provides a feeling of well-being, often associated with childhood or home cooking. Salisbury steaks fit into that category for me. My parents divorced when I was 6 years old, so pretty much my whole childhood my parents both worked two jobs. So aside from my mother’s baked chicken and my father’s minced meat and potatoes, we ate a lot of frozen and prepackaged meals. One of those were On-Cor Salisbury Steaks in Gravy.

I found a recipe for Salisbury Steaks several years ago and had it tucked away in a binder. I finally tried it back in 2008 and it’s been my go-to recipe ever since. The original Salisbury Steak recipe uses 2 pounds of ground beef.

Portobello Salisbury Steaks

Recently I was challenged by The Mushroom Council to experiment with the swapability of mushrooms.

They are currently sponsoring several of the Taste of Home Cooking Schools around the country, so they sent me up there to view the presentation first hand. Taste of Home’s Culinary Specialist is Eric Villegas and I have to say he was so entertaining to watch! While we weren’t able to be up close and personal due to the size of the crowd, video projectors were in place to allow us an up close view of what Eric was demonstrating.

Portobello Salisbury Steaks

Chef Eric showed the audience how substituting mushrooms for some of the red meat (or all of it depending on the recipe) in your dish can save you plenty of fat calories as well as provide essential nutrients from this fabulous vegetable. Audience members watched and learned as Eric demonstrated the swapability technique and its three easy steps – chop, cook and combine. First he chopped the mushrooms similar to the texture of the meat, then he cooked the chopped mushrooms, then he combined the cooked mushrooms with the meat. The mushroom tacos with salsa verde smelled divine!

Armed with some inspiration from the presentation, I decided to revamp my precious Salisbury Steak recipe. the problem that I have, that I’m sure many of you do as well, is there are several mushroomaphobic people in this house. So the only way to really test this out and get some true response was to trick the family.

That’s right. Trick the family.

When I hit the market I decided to buy Portobello mushrooms. Before I continue, and before a debate begins in the comment section, let’s establish that there are two spellings: Portobello and Portabella. The version with the “a” actually comes up as a misspelling in my spell checker, and I have always pronounced the word with the “o”, so that’s where I stand. It’s interchangeable and if you prefer to use the “a” version, then you go ahead. :)

ANOTHER DELICIOUS IDEA >>  Chicken with Peppers and Pasta

I chose Portobello because of its texture and color. They have a deep, dark color, making them very easy to hide in the meat (just sayin’) and they are often used as a substitution for meat in vegetarian recipes (ie. Portobello Mushroom Burgers). If you would like to know more about the different mushroom varieties available out there, The Mushroom Council has a mushroom varieties section here: on their website. This section provides a good cooking overview of which mushrooms work best for salad, sautéing, casseroles, appetizers, raw vs. cooked, stir fries, etc.

Portobello Salisbury Steaks

To try out the swapability technique, I replaced one-half pound of the ground beef with minced mushroom. I chopped the mushroom into large cubes and ran them through my handy dandy food processor. Within 10 seconds I had beautifully minced, dark and rich mushroom pieces. Mmmm!

Portobello Salisbury Steaks

As you can see from the grill picture, the mushroom definitely changes the look of the grill marks. They are more brown than the typical dark brown, almost black marks of just meat.

To see the entire thing in action I’ve put together this video of me making this recipe.

When they were baking in the oven, my 20 year old son and my husband were asking what I was cooking because the aroma was fabulous. When I told them Salisbury Steaks they were excited as it’s one of their favorite meals. Little did they knew I hid their biggest culinary fear inside!

Hubby: “Oh wow. This is good. This is another one of those to put in the “don’t lose this recipe’ file.”

Son: “Oh. My. God. That was the best freakin’ thing I’ve eaten in a long freakin’ time.”


I win!

I didn’t tell them right away, but once I did they handled it pretty well. While my son felt a little betrayed at first, he got over it fast. My husband said he had a feeling that I had done something to the recipe, he still thought it was fabulous. Success!

Portobello Salisbury Steaks

Obviously one of the benefits of swapping mushrooms for some of the meat is the nutritional count. As you can see, just by swapping out half a pound of the meat for mushrooms, you save 100 calories per serving, not to mention all of the other areas that went down, such as fat, cholesterol and carbs.

ANOTHER DELICIOUS IDEA >>  Homemade Onion Rings and Dipping Sauce

Portobello Salisbury Steaks

So don’t be afraid to do a little swapping yourself, even if you have mushroomaphobics like me! Some other recipes I’ve considered trying this with would be tacos, any casserole using ground beef, sausage or ground chicken, lasagna and pasta. What ideas do you have?

5 from 1 reviews
Portobello Salisbury Steaks
Servings: 5 servings
  • 1½ lbs ground beef
  • ½ pound Portobello mushrooms
  • 1 egg white
  • ⅓ cup onion, diced
  • ¼ cup crushed Saltine crackers
  • 2 tbsp 1% milk
  • ¼ tsp salt
  • ⅛ tsp pepper
  • 2 cups brown gravy (homemade, canned, whatever your preference)
  1. Preheat the grill. Preheat oven to 375 F.
  2. Mix all ingredient together in a bowl, use your hands to be sure everything is mixed evenly.
  3. Form 10 oval shaped patties from the meat mixture.
  4. Cook patties on the grill, just enough to get those fabulous grill marks on both sides.
  5. Remove from the grill and put all patties into a 13x9x2 baking pan. Cover patties with brown gravy.
  6. Preheat oven to 375 degrees F. Cover pan tightly with aluminum foil. Bake in oven for 25 minutes.
Stovetop Method: Place grilled meat into a large saute pan or skillet. Cover with gravy. Bring gravy covered steaks to a low boil, reduce heat to a simmer. Cover and simmer for 25 minutes.

NOTE: Nutritional information is without gravy.

Saturated fat: 9.2 g Unsaturated fat: 9.0 g Carbohydrates: 5.8 g Sugar: 1.3 g Fiber: 1.0 g Protein: 28.3 g Cholesterol: 96.8 mg
Nutrition Information
Serving size: 2 patties Calories: 347.5 Fat: 23.4 g

[This post was sponsored by The Mushroom Council. I was compensated for the time that it took me to prepare this recipe and post, but all opinions are 100% mine.] 


  1. says

    Mushrooms are one of my favorite foods! pasta, mushrooms and chicken.. I could live off of those 3 things haha. I love the idea of switching out some of the meat with mushrooms! I made a lasagna a while back with mushrooms instead of meat, and it was just as good! It was just as meaty! Love this recipe! I’ll be making it soon!

  2. Maddie says

    I’m only 13 but looooovvvveee cooking im home schooled so i have a lot of free time and im going to make this for my parents and my 5 siblings tonight!:) i love you website and so does my mom!:)

  3. Pamela I Judson says

    wow! this recipe looks amazing :) and i love that you own it for using canned gravy, good for you:) boy, your comments took me back…. omg! frozen salisbury steak in the ‘boil in the bag’ over toast! i had completely forgotten that (maybe that is not such a bad thing?;) from when i was a kid, my mom served those a lot, oooooh n the creamed chipped beef…. yum! will definitley be trying this one on my mushroom hating hubby ;)

    • says

      Thanks Pamela! Never had the boil in bag, but definitely had the frozen ones a million times. :) Hope you try them and like them as much as we did!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>