TWD: Chocolate Nutella Thumbprint Cookies

I used to make thumbprint cookies every Christmas. Yummy little buttery cookies filled with seedless jams and lemon curd, small enough to pop into your mouth with one bite! Yum.. After reading through this week’s TWD thumbprint cookie recipe and noticing that ground hazelnuts played a big roll, I immediate thought that Nutella would be an ideal filling.

The chocolate (not the Nutella) idea was actually an after thought. I had already rolled one full cookie sheet (by the way, I doubled the size of the cookies, 60 was just too many) when I decided to add a tablespoon of cocoa to the remaining dough. So half of my cookies were as written and the other half were a little chocolatey.

As lovely as they look, I think I made a mistake. You see, as I was grinding the hazelnuts I realized that they weren’t toasted, but raw. The ground nuts were sticking together a little bit, so I was concerned that there would be too much moisture. So I went ahead and toasted the hazelnuts, which brought out the wonderful flavor they possess. However, I think they may have contributed to the cookie’s unfortunate dryness. :( I don’t think the added cocoa had anything to do with the dryness as both versions were equally dry. :-/

I also am not certain if the Nutella was really the ideal filling for these. Perhaps if they were fill halfway through baking, and then allowed to back again, the filling may have set up. Not sure. As soon as you take a bite, and long string of Nutella hits your chin. Still tasty… Nutella is always tasty. :)

I looked back at my own thumbprint recipe, which always turns out tender and buttery, and found that the only ingredients are flour, butter, sugar, orange juice, and an egg yolk. Dorie’s recipe contains flour and ground hazelnuts for the dry ingredients, and sugar, butter and extracts for the wet. There’s no egg yolk or any other liquid. That leads me to believe that she used the moisture from the ground nuts to contribute to the moisture.

Another difference between mine and Dorie’s is that hers bake all the way before filling them. Mine you bake 10 minutes, fill them, then bake 5 minutes more. Dorie boils the jam and fills the cookies after they are baked.

These were fun, they were easy to make, but I still like my thumbprint recipe better. I’ll have to post them one of these days!

Special thanks go out to Mike from Ugly Food for an Ugly Dude (don’t you just LOVE that blog title?? Hee hee!) for hosting this week’s Tuesday With Dorie pick! You can get the recipe from Mike’s blog, or turn to page 164 of Baking From My Home to Yours by the fabulous Dorie Greenspan.

Like what you see? Be sure to subscribe to my newsletter for regular updates and tips!

36 Responses to TWD: Chocolate Nutella Thumbprint Cookies

  1. 1
    noble pig says:

    Okay this is way more brilliant than kisses, I absolutely love it!!

  2. 2
    LDH says:

    Well they sure do look good!!! I love the changes you made.

  3. 3
    Nutmeg Nanny says:

    These look great! I love that you filled them with Nutella. It's the best!

  4. 4
    Susan says:

    Nutella on the chin is better than no Nutella at all! :D Great looking cookies!

  5. 5
    Rachelle @ "Mommy? I'm Hungry!" says:

    I baked mine today and had the dryness/crumbly issue after I baked them, I redented them because they filled back in and some just crumbled apart. I love that you don't bake the jam in these, not a fan of that gooey chewy stuck in your teeth jam, lol. What was nice is the jam sets up nicely after sitting a while. I used almonds for mine, and thought these were great little cookies. =) I too thought chocolate would be fun in these.

  6. 6
    jillbert says:

    They look wonderful, but mine were dry too. I also used Nutella and found that the whole blob came along with the first bite and then I had an empty cookie left. :(

  7. 7
    5 Star Foodie says:

    Scrumptious cookies! I love the filling with Nutella!

  8. 8
    Sue Sparks says:

    Well, they certainly LOOK delicious! I guess I'll just have to try one and see for myself:)

  9. 9
    jose manuel says:

    Que galletas más increibles. Por aquí ese tipo de galletas se hacen poco. Las tuyas tienen una pinta estupenda. Gracias por la receta. Un saludo desde España

  10. 10
    MaryMoh says:

    Looks very delicious! I can imagine biting into it and the Nutella bursting in your mouth…yum

  11. 11
    Marthe says:

    Both your versions of the thumbprints look delicious!!

  12. 12
    mike says:

    I don't think these look dry at all! There's a few cracks here and there (just like mine), but they look nutty, crumbly (a good-crumbly) and the Nutella filling is wonderful. Love the addition of cocoa – what a great idea!

  13. 13
    Mary says:

    They look really nice with Nutella in them! I also thought 60 cookies was too much, so I halved the recipe. I filled mine with lemon curd, and I didn't find them dry at all. They were like shortbread.

  14. 14
    Romaine says:

    Like you, I prefer my own recipe with an egg yolk added. Nutella sounds tasty even if it is messy. Very nice pictures.

  15. 15
    Deeva says:

    Yessss, nutella. MMMMMM! That one photo of the half eaten cookie and the nutella just sitting there, yea that's a great one.

  16. 16
    Nickki says:

    Your cookies look delicious! I also thought of adding nutella but I didn't, definitely next time though! I would happily eat nutella straight from the jar – who am I kidding, I DO ;-)

  17. 17
    Megan says:

    They look delicious! But I'll wait for your recipe!

  18. 18
    Debbie says:

    I think they look delicious Amanda….

  19. 19
    Katrina says:

    Now THOSE are for us big guys (gals)!
    And great minds think alike. I knew there would be many who used Nutella, as did I. I loved them. I didn't think they were too dry and I even overbaked some of mine–a little crumbly, but a great texture.

  20. 20
    Maria says:

    Why did you make these? Now I have to make them and eat the whole batch:)

  21. 21
    myfamousrecipe says:

    Your post reminded me that I had to add a good bit of water to the dough in order to get these to roll into balls. They were too dry and crumbly to work with at first. Anyway, Nutella!? Yum!

  22. 22
    biz319 says:

    My daughter was introduced to Nutella at the age of 8, when I met my now Italian husband – she loves the stuff, and it will be in her future apartment! :D

    The cookies look pretty though!

  23. 23
    Sweet and Savory says:

    Thanks for the commentary. No matter some of the minor issues, your cookies look fantastic.

  24. 24
    Chef Fresco says:

    Nutella is legal crack.

  25. 25
    Tia says:

    i like your analysis of the nuts adding moisture. i love reaidng stuff like that.

  26. 26
    Heather says:

    They look good! Not one of my favourite recipes but will have to find another version of thumbprints too try.

  27. 27
    Lauryn says:

    Thats too bad that they came out dry! They look amazing!! I'm surprised that the nutella wasnt a better filling. I used dark chocolate in some of mine and they were great!!

  28. 28
    Flourchild says:

    They look very good. I loved this recipe and will make it again!

  29. 29
    Rachel says:

    A good reason to eat Nutella! :) Your cookies look super yummy!

  30. 30
    Alisa says:

    Yum!I love nutella, and I think your cookies look wonderful!

  31. 31
    Amalia says:

    GOOD GOD I wish I had nutella just about now! ):
    I would love to hear about your recipe btw! I'm always looking for different interesting cookie recipes and so far I've loved all of yours! Yum! Oh yes I'm Amalia, Nice to meet you (:


  32. 32
    CB says:

    What a great idea. Adding cocoa powder. Now I wanna try that the next time I bake these cookies. Sorry yours came out dry. :( I was a little suprised that Dorie's recipe didn't have eggs either. I used almond meal instead of ground hazelnuts and the texture wasn't dry for me.

  33. 33
    Erin@The Sweet Life says:

    You did it! When I ate my first Thumbprint tonight filled with blackberry jam, I thought to myself, "I shoulda filled these with Nutella!" But just last week I ate what was left of my jar. Straight out of the jar. With a spoon. Therapy in the form of chocolate hazelnut spread. Anyway, your cookies look delicious!

  34. 34
    Teanna says:

    I'm sorry these weren't a hit with you, but I loved reading your comparisons between your go-to recipe and Dorie! And I love the description of the Nutella coming out in a string and landing on your chin! That is so accurate! But I do love what you did with the recipe! You're brilliant, woman!

  35. 35
    Jacque says:

    Well, they sure *look* good. Sorry they didn't measure up. It's hard to beat a favorite recipe.

  36. 36
    Avanika [YumsiliciousBakes] says:

    No one would know you had so many problems with these! They look amazing :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>