4cupsvegetable oilor shortening, for frying - about 4-5 cups
Instructions
Fill a heavy bottom pot 3-4 inches deep with shortening or vegetable oil. Heat over medium high until the oil reaches 375°F. You will need to adjust the burner temp regularly during frying to maintain oil at precisely 375°F. Clip a candy thermometer on the pot to be able to regularly monitor the temperature.
Whisk together pancake mix and water until a few lumps remain - the mixture should be thick enough to coat an Oreo, but thin enough that excess batter with drip off the Oreo.
Dip an Oreo cookie into the pancake batter, tossing it to coat evenly on both sides. Lift the Oreo from the batter using a fork and quickly tap off any excess batter.
Transfer the cookie gently into the heated oil and fry for 2-3 minutes, flipping the Oreo once the first side is golden brown.
Lift the golden brown oreo from the oil with a slotted spoon and place on paper towels to soak up excess oil. Continue coating, frying, and straining the Oreos, adding several at a time to the oil, but maintaining the ideal fry temperature of 375°F.
Fried Oreos are best eaten immediately after frying.
The batter will coat a full standard size package of Oreo cookies.
A Dutch oven works best for stovetop “deep frying” as it maintain the most even temperature. The oil temperature will fluctuate as you add Oreos to it - try to adjust the burner regularly to ensure that you keep the temperature as close to 375°F as possible. A hotter oil will overcook the Oreos before the batter has had time to cook through. A colder oil temperature will result in the cookies soaking up too much oil while trying to achieve that cooked, golden color.
You can use any pancake batter - simply follow the instructions on the pancake batter box and thin, as needed, until the batter is a consistency that will coat the Oreos evenly. We used Krusteax because it is so simple to just add water.