Cantaloupe Cream Pie

Cantaloupe cream pie – something I hadn’t heard of until just recently. Really, it sounded a little weird to me. I mean, come on, cantaloupe? In a pie? Turns out, there are recipes for not only cantaloupe, but others melon, and even watermelon! Well, I’m game for almost anything, especially a flavor like cantaloupe, which I love, and the fact that it’s a dessert just locked it in.

In case you’re wondering how I actually came across this idea, it wasn’t completely mine. I work for Old Fashioned Living as their editor. A site visitor named Lydia had written to me after having trouble with a recipe… for cantaloupe cream pie. The recipes was posted within the article “Harvesting and Using Fresh Cantaloupe“, amongst other interesting recipes such as cantaloupe bread and cantaloupe preserves.

Lydia wrote:

“I was making the above recipe, and during the step that says cook over medium heat for 8-10 minutes, stirring constantly, the mixture did not boil nor become thick, it more resembled thick scrambled  eggs – it didn’t ‘glug pop’ boil like pudding sometimes does. The texture was really weird, it was not smooth like pudding, was not appealing.  It was almost as if the eggs gave it a weird texture because they started to ‘turn scrambled’ in the saucepan.” 

Having made several ice creams and custards before, I decided to test the recipe out myself, to see if I could help Lydia troubleshoot and figure out what went wrong. When I made this pie, I was successful, everything went as described in the recipe. I have a feeling that Lydia’s issues rose from either having the heat too low for too long, or perhaps she pureed the cantaloupe first before measuring, making the mixture too thin.

ANOTHER DELICIOUS IDEA >>  Chocolate Chip Cookies and Fudge Puddles

Now on with the review. First off, you must allow this pie to stay in the refrigerator overnight. It just needs that long to set up. It’s delicious, but definitely needs the whipping cream to offset the sweetness of the custard. Obviously I had a bit of whipping cream overload, I did that just to get enough height to fill and mound up in the pie shell.

While this was very good, and none of it went to waste, here are the things I would do differently next time:

1) I’d definitely make this as a tart next time, instead of a pie. A tart is shorter and this custard, as you can see from the picture, is quite short itself. Dorie Greenspan’s book, Baking From My Home To Yours, has an excellent tart dough recipe.

2) For a pie, I would actually combine the custard and whipped cream by gently folding them together until nicely combined. This would soften the sweetness a bit and would actually create more of a mousse type texture, and would allow for more height.

I’ve rewritten the instructions from those that were on the site to make them clearer and easy to follow.

Cantaloupe Cream Pie
adapted from Old Fashioned Living
printable version

1 cup granulated sugar
2 tablespoons flour
3 eggs, beaten
1 cup cantaloupe
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 tablespoons unsalted butter
1 8″ pastry shell, baked
1 cup whipping cream

ANOTHER DELICIOUS IDEA >>  Vanilla Bread Pudding

Combine the sugar and flour in a saucepan; add eggs, use a whisk to mix well. Puree the cantaloupe in a blender. You should get about 2/3 cup of puree from one cup of chopped cantaloupe. Add the puree to the egg mixture and whisk to combine.

Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly with a wooden spoon, the mixture will begin thickening rather quickly. Cook until mixture boils and thickens, about 8 to 10 minutes. Remove from heat, add the vanilla and butter, stir until smooth.

Place custard into a bowl and allow it to cool. While custard is cooling, bake pastry shell and set aside to cool.

Put the custard into the baked shell. Using the whisk attachment, beat the whipping cream on high speed until stiff peaks form; spread evenly over top of custard. Allow pie to set in refrigerator overnight for best results.

More from me you might like:
Homemade Cherry Pie Filling
Amanda’s Espresso Chocolate Pie
Grasshopper Pie
Homemade Baker’s Square French Silk Pie

More from the interwebs:
Cantaloupe Pie – from Recipezaar (uses cream cheese and gelatin)
Cantaloupe Pie – from Diana’s Desserts
Seafoam Cantaloupe Pie – from Vintage Cookbooks

(If you enjoyed this post, I’d truly appreciate a stumble, Digg, facebook share, whatever you like! :) )

NEW! Be sure to subscribe to my newsletter, Foodie in the Craftroom, to receive updates and tips from both Amanda’s Cookin’ and Crafts by Amanda! Visit


  1. Cookie Madness says

    That is wild! I'll bet it tastes good, though. It's definitely a conversaton starter. I like your idea of doing it as a tart.

  2. TeaLady says

    Yeah, mine was lumpy, like tapioca. But tasted good. I will try your recipe next. It is interesting that you can make pie with canteloupe. Who knew!!

  3. Kristen says

    It looks and sounds divine!
    I am horrible at pie crusts but yours is gorgeous. Care to share how you get the beautiful waves in your crust?

  4. Kathy@theshebearofeleven says

    I would never have thought of cantaloupe pie, yours looks so good. I've been adding cantaloupe to my smoothies and they taste good.

  5. Carol says

    Amanda, that looks absolutely delicious. I wouldn't have thought to use cantaloupe in pie-but I think I'll be dreaming of it now! :)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>